
Who dat?


Last week's anouncement that Andre Dawson would be inducted into the baseball Hall of Fame as a Montreal Expo against his will led radio commentator Dan Patrick to declare that an all-time team of Nos Amours would compare favourably against the best any other franchise has to offer. Of course, I couldn't agree more, but coming from the American sports media, that is generally pre-occupied with ridiculing anything Canadian, it was quite a shock. Let me begin by saying that I am a big fan of Patrice Cormier. Not only is his brother, Kevin, one of the most popular players in the history of my hometown Halifax Mooseheads, but he is a fantastic player who I think has what it takes to have a successful NHL career. He looks to me like one of those guys who actually plays better at the professional level than in junior (a la Patrice Bergeron).
All that said, I am at a loss to find any excuse whatsoever for the hit in Mikael Tam. To me, elbowing an unsuspecting player while skating at full-speed is about as dirty and unforgivable an act a hockey player can commit. It is on par with clubbing another player over the head with a stick and there is no possible justification. What Cormier did is far more deplorable and dangerous than Michael Liambis' hit a few months ago that resulted in a lifetime suspension from the OHL. The Liambis' suspension, in my view, was extraordinarily harsh, but it sets a precedent that may make life more difficult for Cormier, if not Gilles Courteau.
Using Liambis as a barometer, Cormier should be kicked out of the QMJHL forever...period. However, if one recognizes that David Branch went over the top when he made his ruling, a less harsh punishment could be applied. I don't think that disciplinary decisions should take the skill and value of a player (offender or victim) into account, but there is no doubt that Liambis' suspension would have been shorter had he not been a fourth line role player.
Rouyn-Noranda has 20 games left on its regular season schedule. Under the circumstances, it would be appropriate for Cormier to miss all of those games and the first round of the playoffs. I don't believe that this kid's junior career should be ended by this incident (he's only 20 years old) but, on the other hand, a serious message needs to be sent to him (and everyone else in hockey) that this is about as bad as it gets.